DIY Planner - Review: First Impressions of the Eee PC 701 - Comments

Resistance Crumbling

Rocket Jones — Sat, 19 Jul 2008 11:50:00 -0400

My daughter has used her eeePC now for an entire year of college and still loves it, while I've been resisting the urge to pick one up for myself.

She's had two hiccups. Firstly, her wireless setup was very difficult because her school uses an obscure protocol, which is apparently standard-ish amongst US colleges. She needed help from the tech support people at her school to figure it out, but they got it going and even managed wireless printing, which was an unexpected bonus.

The second hiccup happened when a software upgrade crashed in the middle of the update, rendering the wee beastie non-startable. By pressing F5 during the boot sequence, you get an option screen that can completely reset your machine to original condition for just such an occasion. Works great. Fortunately, she had current backups!!!

The eeePC can make an impression as well. She attended a conference in the Spring, doing multiple interviews for Summer jobs (she works in theater). She set up the eeePC to open directly to her online portfolio, which the interviewers could then see. She'd also hand them a one-page summary with her URL prominently displayed so they could go back and review it again later if they wanted. She got a lot of favorable comments on the setup, and more than one interviewer referred to her as "mini laptop girl" as a distinguishing characteristic.

I really want my own eeePC, but at this time it would be just to play with. That's a fair bit of money to spend on a toy, and the new model is more expensive, even overpriced, IMO.

...and after three more months...

Jon Rutherford — Sat, 19 Jul 2008 08:50:59 -0400

Thought I'd update my original "after one month" comment to reflect my feelings about the EeePC here in the middle of July, a little over four months since I acquired it.

I still admire and appreciate its ultra-solid construction every time I open it (with some difficulty -- which is good, since it's virtually impossible for it to open on its own while it's under your arm in the espresso stand line, for example, or if you drop it -- in which case it will most likely emerge both still shut and undamaged, amazing).

The display continues to impress me with its clarity and ease on my eyes. I thought my desktop 19-inch Princeton monitor was easy to look at, but now I actually prefer using the EeePC when I don't need all that screen space.

I loathe the built-in touchpad, though, and pretty much refuse to use it. A wireless mouse I found on eBay for about two dollars (that's right, $2) is so wonderful I lack words to describe it. Problem solved. (The "dongle" that goes into the USB slot on the EeePC even stows in the back of the mouse, and turns it off at the same time, when you want to wrap things up and move on.)

I generally do all my work (mainly, I admit, email, a spreadsheet, and browsing and doing research on the Web; I'm retired) in the living room on the EeePC and rarely even visit my desktop machine anymore. If I can fire myself up to get involved heavily in photography again (I hit a slump when I resigned from Flickr), then I'll do all photo editing on the desktop machine.

I would rate my satisfaction with the 701 at 9 on a scale of ten. I would probably rate the larger machine even higher, but I don't have any plan to get one, at this time.

Eee PC

selang1 — Mon, 14 Jul 2008 19:49:01 -0400

Love mine can use free wi-fi in my local bar while I wait for friends and most of our express buses have wi-fi too.
Great for on the move. Storage, I just use my cards and pen drives. It is a sweetie

Eeepc after a month

Jon Rutherford — Sun, 6 Apr 2008 23:17:45 -0400

(First -- Doug, your pen articles are absolutely first-rate.)

I've had my black Eeepc 4G Surf for about one month now and have little but praise for it. It is extraordinarily solid-feeling, more than any notebook computer I've had or used before. The keyboard does take getting used to but I can now type at about 60 of my usual 80-90 wpm with no trouble -- except for that pesky caps lock key that I invariably hit when wanting "a" at least once per email, etc. I've seldom in my 50-plus years of typing ever used a caps lock key. Like the "scroll lock" key I wonder why they even exist. (I also never use a right shift key. You'd have to see it to understand.)

It took many hours to get wireless home networking to work. That is in no way the fault of the Eeepc; it's because tutorials on the Web are confusing, contradictory, and sometimes downright wrong. When I finally got it going, it was ridiculously simple (by Linux standards). Only three little files to put on the server computer and I was all set.

The display is a marvel. I bought mine on reading many reviews that bragged about the clarity of the display. I didn't go wrong.

I found an excellent wireless mouse on eBay for about $10 and that gets around the tiny touchpad problem. Settings for the touchpad can make it a lot less troublesome to use, but I've never liked any touchpad a bit, and this is no exception.

For those worried (or concerned) about the supposedly relatively short life of solid-state "drives," I have done extensive reading about that, and it appears, subject to verification, that that is now a myth -- no need to worry about wearing it out, probably, in the lifetime of the machine, or possibly even mine. These are not like the very first solid-state memory devices.

All in all, the Eeepc is better than I hoped it would be -- by quite a bit. And I had high hopes else I wouldn't have ordered mine.

Free Austin WiFi...

Anonymous — Sun, 30 Mar 2008 13:58:14 -0400

It looks like there are lots of free WiFi spots in Austin. Look at the following link. But I don't know how up-to-date this listing is--haven't used it myself.

wififreespot DOT com/tex.html

And welcome to Texas, I hope you have a great time.

HTH!

Glenda

Wifi

The Bear — Sun, 30 Mar 2008 11:21:32 -0400

I need to clarify that I'm Scottish so of course I want free WiFi ;-)

I'm going to Austin, TX and I know I have free wifi in the hotel but hoping with it being a University town (and home of a few electronics manufacturers) there might be a few free wifi spots about. It'll only be in between kayaking and eating bbq anyway

In the UK I am fairly happy surfing in the pub! I'd be interested to know if there is 3g/mobile broadband connection in Cornwall. While camping last year we couldnt connect anywhere remotely in the country in England...

Your other solution would be

Tournevis — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 17:53:22 -0400

Your other solution would be to move to Montreal or Toronto, both city having ample free wireless, both inside and outside, the latter of the two havinf a municipal plan to provide free wireless to all residents.

US Wireless

Anonymous — Sat, 29 Mar 2008 02:26:36 -0400

It's not free everywhere, but you can go to most any McDonald's, FedEx Kinko, Borders Bookstores,or Starbucks and get on T-Mobile for a reasonable fee per month--like $40. And most hotels and motels have it. Google T-Mobile Hotspot and you can find a listing of all their "Hotspots."

AlphaSmart

DeanG — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 22:09:43 -0400

or the AlphaSmart NEO

Mobile Internet

reepicheep — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 21:55:48 -0400

... in the UK and unfortunately WiFi isn't as common ...

Major UK cities have WiFi networks but you'll have to pay for the access. Starbucks have a tie in to T-Mobile in most (all?) of their shops, for example. Business hotels provide it. If a student then many British universities now have WiFi networks installed. Alternatively there are now mobile broadband modems from T-Mobile and 3. Faster than my own wireless network, which is broadcasting from a router connected to my 100Mb network backbone. But the mobile broadband has traffic limiting; 3Gb/month is common. I hope it isn't 3G specific as I'm off on business to Cornwall next week and 3G coverage is pretty much non-existant there; I'll be miffed if it doesn't fallback to using the existing 2G network.

As the eee uses Linux it might be simple to use one of the broadband devices. Equally might be real difficult. But the Apple Mac stuff installed without problem here.

Depends on the city.

caligatia — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 17:02:59 -0400

I live in a college town in north-central Florida, and wi-fi is everywhere here. All the coffeeshops have it. The downtown area has blanket coverage thanks to a city initiative. All the county library branches have it. Even some restaurants in the student-heavy areas have it. And of course the very large university has it. (Weirdly, the community college does not have it yet. Surprising, considering they have an excellent IT program. I hear they're working on it though.)

--
Steff
[ blog | photos ]

WiFi - common?

emoore — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 16:38:17 -0400

Not where I live. It's not as common in the U.S. as many people think. I live in a small city in the SE U.S. and there is one spot in town that has WiFi access but they have only 4 chairs with 2 tiny (2 ft. diam) tables and it is a lunch spot. There are more urban areas where it is more common but I travel quite a bit to larger cities for work and there are times when the only free wireless I can find is at my hotel.

eee pc is indeed great

The Bear — Thu, 27 Mar 2008 23:59:13 -0400

I've had the eee pc since January and it's seldom far from my grasp now. Great for working on the move. Good for surfing and email. It's not bad for watching videos on either though maybe not a film.

I'm in the UK and unfortunately WiFi isn't as common as I think it is in the USA, but if I have to have a beer in order to sit in a wifi zone I can live with it. I'll certainly be bringing it to the states on my holidays to upload photos and surf on the move.

I'm a total paper notebook addict but the eee pc is really tempting me away, despite it's daft name!!!!

I WAS tempted, now an owner.

Richard T Perry — Fri, 21 Mar 2008 16:13:24 -0400

>is there a way to play Civilization III on it?

Yes, several different ways.

1) Install WinXP and run.
2) Add the "advanced mode" to the desktop under the Xandros/Linux OS and then install Cedega (which DOES cost a little money) and run under that.
3) Consider FreeCiv as a substitue - I was playing that last night on my EEE.

I will tell you though - I was USED to playing games like this on my 21" monitor - the EEE in this particular ap suffers from information overload/undersize a bit. Works, though!

Obsession with FPs is OK...

wikeh2004 — Thu, 13 Mar 2008 19:27:26 -0400

I have it too and the only downsides have been keeping my purchases under the radar of my generally tolerant wife, and the struggle not to yield to temptation when another attractive vintage pen shows up for sale... :-)

They are so much fun to write with and are such beautiful works of art.

Looking forward to your next article.

Walter

-----------------------
"The only reason for time is so that everything doesn't happen at once." Albert Einstein and Buckaroo Banzai

Review: First Impressions of the Eee PC 701

dougj — Wed, 5 Mar 2008 14:27:53 -0500

Okay, I can be a little obsessive. (For example, see my recent posts about fountain pens, fountain pens, fountain pens, and ...erm... fountain pens.) Unfortunately, combined with my persistent belief that my next productivity tool could be the non plus ultra, this can translate into drawers filled with unused gadgets, bookcases jammed with partially used planners and notebooks, and a selection of writing utensils that would shame any office supply store. And, although I am embarrassed to admit it, while I tend towards the intimacy of pen and paper, the tinker in me is certainly inclined towards items demonstrating an almost awkward complexity. But do those help me be more productive? Rarely.

I've mentioned not only my Macs in these pages, but my Palms, my Newtons, and various other attempts to find a perfect portable writing machine that also allows for efficient time management. The Newton eMate 300 (or alternatively, the Newton MessagePad 2100 with keyboard) was the closest thing thus far, as it offered me the ability to write without being tempted by the distractions of the web, use the amazing MoreInfo to structure my days, and have a smallish and rugged package that lasted up to 20 hours. But, as attractive as the Newtons were, I started yearning for the ability to look up online resources, draw small diagrams, send email, sync easily with my other computers, and so on, all of which are possible on the Newtons, but not easy nor intuitive. The thought of typing several dozen pages on a cramped smartphone thumb-board while the battery ticks down didn't seem to offer any respite. What I needed was a very small laptop... a subnotebook, and one that wouldn't cost a fortune. And then, I unexpectedly received one: an Asus Eee PC 701 4G Surf, currently going for an average retail value of roughly $350 USD ($400 for the non-Surf model, which means it has a webcam).

I eyed it suspiciously. Small, clunky, inexpensive, tiny-screened, Linuxy, and therefore decidedly un-Mac-like. Could it fit the bill?

After extracting it from its small box and laying it on my desk, I couldn't help but notice that the Eee PC (pronounced "eeeeeeee pee cee"?) was smaller and roughly the same weight as the mid-size hardback book lying next to it. It's a black model, as sexy as possible for such an inelegant and squarish creature, although one can find white, green, baby blue and pink versions if so inclined. Still, the plastic shell seems rather strong and well reinforced. It looks like it could withstand some rough treatment, and indeed it has. As I lifted the screen, I noted that the hinge was a little stiff, but seeing that there isn't a catch to secure it, this would prove necessary. I plugged the small and lightweight charger --about the size of a cell phone's-- into the wall and pressed the power switch.

In about 15-20 seconds, a modified Linux operating system appeared, sporting large tasteful icons within a tabbed interface. The icons were generic in nature -- instead of OpenOffice.org Writer, for example, the Work tab provided access to Documents, and instead of Amarok, there was a Music Manager. As the "Eee" in Eee PC stands for "Easy to learn, easy to work, easy to play", developed no doubt for a significant demographic of small children and grandparents, this made perfect sense.

First things first: that screen is small. At 7" and a resolution of 800x480, don't expect to do any high-end design work on this. Even viewing webpages designed for much larger monitors can be a little trying. Sitting next to my 17" MacBook Pro, the effect is almost comical, like toddler standing next to a Harlem Globetrotter. The screen size, more than anything else, would be the source of most issues on this machine.

The keyboard is small, too. I'm a very big boy with big hands, and at first it proved almost impossible to touch-type as I normally do (roughly 60-80 WPM on my regular Mac keyboards). I had the same problem at first with the eMate, but like its funkier predecessor, all it took was an hour or two of practice to get used to the spacing of the keys. I still occasionally miss the right shift key and hit the up arrow, royally screwing up my paragraph, but that's happening less and less now.

The trackpad is also tiny, but I don't find this a hassle at all. The sensitivity is fine for my uses, and one can slide a finger along its right side to scroll a page. A mouse, though, is still my preferred option on every computer, and I did get a nice tiny black mouse with a retractable cable. They make quite a cute combination. Not that I'm into cute. Except for my wife. Ahem.

This being a Linux box, it didn't take long for me to start diving under the hood, turning on the advanced desktop mode (a.k.a., KDE), setting up some repositories, and delving once more into my time-honoured UNIX geekiness. The base ("easy") system doesn't allow access to easily install the many thousands of free applications out there, but I'm sure the typical ten-year-old will figure it out very quickly. Since it uses a Debian-style apt-get system, if you're proficient, you can fetch and install anything within seconds, and you won't have to worry about virii, spyware, or endless software costs.

So, how do the rest of the machine's specifications measure up?

Processor: 900 MHz Celeron - surprisingly zippy with Linux!
Operating System: Linux (Xandros based), although it is possible to install WinXP and Vista on it -- from what I understand, the latter experience provides an excellent opportunity for masochists
Memory: 512 MB RAM, although it's possible to upgrade using regular non-proprietary laptop RAM sticks
Storage: 4 GB solid state (on the 4G, with other options being the 2G and the 8G), not a hard drive. This means that it's quite fast with data access, unlike several other UMPCs. About half of that 4 GB is taken up by the OS, which still leaves a lot of "working" room for documents. However, if you have a lot of music and video, I'd recommend using either a nice big thumb drive or the ...
Card reader: SD/MMC or SDHC -- a card fits flush inside, so you can install a roomy 4 GB or higher to hold big(ger) media files
Ports: Three USB 2.0 ports, a VGA out (capable of 1024x768, perfect for a projector), Kensington lock, mic in, audio out, and the aforementioned SD reader -- no Firewire, but no one is likely to use this rig for video editing
Webcam: only on certain (non-"Surf") models -- it isn't included on my 4G Surf
Battery: roughly three hours, depending on usage and settings -- surprisingly, I watched a 110 minute movie using VLC, and still had enough juice left for nearly an hour's browsing
Networking: built-in ethernet and wireless, both of worked without any hassle
Missing bits? - No internal CD or DVD optical drive, no expansion cards, no modem, no replaceable hard drive -- these, of course, aren't insurmountable, since the machine seems to have recognised every USB device I've thrown at it
Weight: less than 1 kg (roughly two pounds), which doesn't feel like much in a backpack or messenger bag
Bundled Software: OpenOffice.org (word processor, spreadsheet, presentations, etc.), Firefox browser, Thunderbird email client, a handful of addictive games, several utilities, and a score of other small but useful applications that only become revealed in advanced desktop mode

So, is it a perfect fit with my writing and productivity cycles? Not quite, although it does have more going for it than not. I like the light weight and the compact size: I can haul it out on a moment's notice and start using it within five seconds or so. I love Linux and the horde of free software out there, but the temptation for me to get lost in tinkering is great, so that might ding my productivity a bit. ("Ooo! I can install the Beryl 3D desktop!") The keyboard and trackpad may be cramped, but most people will eventually get used to them. And the included software is a top-notch collection that allows me to do most day-to-day tasks I generally do on a computer.

Still, the screen size is the biggest issue. It's fine for basic word processing, but graphics work becomes difficult --the basic Gimp toolbars and panels take up half the screen. Video playback using VLC, on the other hand, displays a wide-screen DivX with sharp colours, good contrast, great sound (via earbuds), and no discernable skipping or artifacting.

Likewise, browsing certain websites becomes a chore in sliding scrollbars back and forth, although this can be mostly rectified by using Opera and its ability to scale everything on the screen to fit by width, especially in full-screen mode --a brilliant touch for mobile browsers! I attempted to use Google Docs, Google Calendar and Backpack for productivity purposes, and eventually tripped upon the idea of setting up Prisms for each of them that eliminated the need for toolbars and the like. (Or one could hit F11 in Firefox to jump into full-screen mode.) Those online apps work well (notwithstanding the nearly three weeks my co-op's net connection has been broken at home) and they allow me to access the same data from any net-connected computer. (Alas, just not at home, did I mention? Grrr.)

Obviously, between the tiny screen and the low specs, this isn't an ideal primary machine, but it makes a darned fine secondary laptop, one that you can toss in a small bag and forget about till you need it, something I've been doing quite a bit lately. I must admit that I really miss MoreInfo on the Newton, probably the single best time management tool I've ever used, but the Eee PC does signal a wave worth catching -- the ultra-cheap, ultra-mobile computing experience.

For more information, check out Amazon.com, the official ASUS Eee PC site, and the EeeUser wiki and blog. Note that a new 9" Eee PC model was just announced, but the price is starting to creep upwards into the cost of a full-fledged laptop; much more, I'd be sore tempted to get a MacBook 13" instead.

Next week, more about fountain pens....

D*I*Y Planner - Review: First Impressions of the Eee PC 701 - Comments